If you’re any sort of gossip fiend, you know that actor Ryan Reynolds was once engaged to Alanis Morissette. He’s not anymore. Now Reynolds is dating starlet Scarlett Johansson. But this blog has nothing to do with Reynolds himself, because he’s actually not interesting and sort of talentless. It’s about his current love and ex-betrothed both releasing studio albums on May 20.
I was just sort of sitting here wondering if it’s any sort of contest. I mean, it’s Alanis Freakin’ Morissette, the girl I thought invented scorned anger the first time I heard “You Oughta Know” in the fifth grade. “Jagged Little Pill” was my first CD, and I remember memorizing breathless lyrics like “Does she go down on you in a theater?” loooong before I knew what the term meant. That song was supposedly about Dave Coulier, for God’s sake! How could a charmed 23-year-old like Scarlett ever compare?
When I first read that Ms. Scarlett is releasing “Anywhere I Lay My Head,” a collection of re-interpreted Tom Waits covers, I couldn’t help but roll my eyes a little bit. OF COURSE A HOLLYWOOD ACTRESS WOULD RELEASE AN ALBUM ALMOST EXCLUSIVELY FULL OF COVERS [only one song is original]!!!! It really drives me nuts that these Hollywood people can spew forth all sorts of merchandise (garbage) left and right just because they feel like it … but oh, well … I feel blessed it’s a CD and not a fashion line.
I just clicked on the “Listening Party” section of Johansson’s website, www.scarlettalbum.com, and gave “Anywhere” 25 minutes of my time. She told Spin’s David Marchese that her producer, Dave Sitek of TV on the Radio, suggested her album sound like a mix of too much cough syrup and Tinkerbell hallucinations.
That’s exactly what happens on this record. Ummm, mission accomplished?
But you know what? It’s not horrible. The track “I Don’t Wanna Grow Up” reminds me of that scene in “Lost in Translation” when Scarlett and Bill Murray are in that karaoke bar. If that song had started pumping through the speakers, it would’ve fit perfectly with those zebra-striped walls, not to mention that ridiculous pink wig. It’s very electro pop look-at-me-I’m-shopping-at-Urban-Outfitters. I dig it.
I also like “I Wish I Was in New Orleans,” even if it sounds like one of those background songs to a Volkswagen commercial where two middle-class people drive into a field to look at stars through the sunroof.
That’s about all I like. I do not enjoy the lead single, “Falling Down,” because I think Scarlett’s voice has too much echo and makes her sound like she’s dying at the bottom of a well somewhere. The song’s only redeeming quality is David Bowie. That man could record himself blowing his nose for three hours and I’d still listen to it.

Which now brings me to Alanis. I love Alanis. I really do. I love her oblong face, her spirally hair and I especially love the fact that she looks like someone who would make an excellent dive bar drinking companion. I bet she’d be totally cool about it if I accidentally spilled half a pint of Guinness on her.
With that being said, I also happen to love Imogen Heap of Frou Frou. Alanis enlisted Guy Sigsworth (who worked with Heap as electro duo Frou Frou) as a writer for her newest disc, “Flavors of Entanglement,” and the result is that zippy, pretty music I enjoy so much. I especially love the song “Moratorium,” because it’s beautiful and because, once again, Alanis lets all of us pissed off females out there know it’s okay to give a middle finger to relationships.
Alanis is counting down to a big tour, and her life is documented on a neat little Flash application on her Web site, www.alanis.com. Seeing photos of her dogs and her friends in places like Amsterdam and Geneva just sort of reinforce the idea I have of her being incredibly down-to-earth and fun to be around. ScarJo, on the other hand? I’d be scared of accidentally stepping on her Manolos and pissing her off.
So, in short, Scarlett’s album doesn’t totally suck. Okay. But Alanis’ albums never suck, and this new disc preserves the old, emotional style of hers we know and love while playing around with a new brand of niceness that’s refreshing after years and years of pissed off copycats.

Duh … Alanis wins. Did you think for a second I’d pick Scarlett?